The THIS IS NOT A GRIFT Team apologise for that email.
We set up another Substack to try and test the boundaries of how far Substack’s “free speech” / disinformation machine could be pushed. We are dunces who can’t use this platform properly.
Hi all, This Is Not A Grift — a newsletter you probably forgot you signed up to — would like to break character to tell you we are leaving Substack.
It has become clear Substack allows Nazis — TERFs, climate change deniers, and all manner of other terrible people — to spread misinformation and hatred as well as profit from that hatred. By doing nothing to remove, and also algorithmically supporting these ghouls to grow their following, Substack makes money from this hatred.
This Is Not A Grift was set up as a satirical comment on the grindcore hashtag startup life. But even a satirical Substack cannot, in good conscience, continue to use a platform which is itself turning more and more into a grift: skimming their 10 percent off of the worst people in the world.
posed the question to his subscribers on whether Webworm should move off Substack. This is my comment (with some slight edits for spelling / grammar / clarity, original is here):
Move.
The argument sunlight disinfects hate speech is categorically incorrect. Arguing with Nazis didn’t work in Weimar Germany. They, and other fascist groups, were allowed to set up their own newspapers and physical newsletters. That allowed their ideas to spread with a veneer of respectability. It also allowed them to start getting money to fund more propaganda and from there organise the hatred they whipped up. We know how that ended up for Jewish people, homosexuals, and other groups.
If we rewind 90 years and Substack was a printing press with a mail order service and you had to go in and queue up with Nazis, would you feel comfortable standing in line next to a dude who hates you for not being straight?
You walk over to the owner of the printing press as thousands of copies of a newsletter with the headline “TRUTH ABOUT THE JEWISH CONSPIRACY” are being printed out behind him and he’s there smiling saying no no no it’s all okay, and as you’re talking the Nazi who you were in queue next to hands the owner an envelope full of cash (sourced from other terrible people) and the owner doesn’t say anything as the Nazi spits on you as he leaves.
That is literally what is happening.
Substack is profiting off of hate speech. Substack is knowingly empowering Nazis to grow their networks and leverage the respectability of the platform to gain credibility. Nazis (and other violent horrible people) are crowdfunding their propaganda machine and that cash will then be diverted into supporting other horrendous things.
And all the while Substack sits there claiming some sort of moral high ground as the Nazis do their Nazi shit and start spreading their ideas to bring in more paid subscribers so that substack can profit off hate speech to pay back their VC funded investors.
In the past 10 years we’ve seen a massive explosion of online misinformation, disinformation, and hate speech. Nazis are already tapping into disaffected conspiracy communities to gain followers and supporters. In New Zealand, in the aftermath of the rightwing terror attack on Christchurch mosques, there are still conspiracy delusionists primed and ready for some nice Nazi to pill them. In Melbourne, Nazis feel so empowered they will come out in broad daylight to support TERFs and even openly sing racist songs on trains they commandeer.
We cannot appease Nazis. The only correct answer is to de-platform them and hound them so their ideas cannot spread, counter protest, and perhaps — if it really comes down to it — punch ‘em in the face.
Why? Because it’s not enough to be neutral when it comes to hate.
Substack claims to be acting in the name of free speech, but free speech cannot exist if other people are afraid to talk because Nazis (TERFs, etc) are literally threatening people of colour, Jewish people, trans-people, etc with violence, rape, murder, genocide. This is the paradox in any discussion about free speech that these right wing reprobates lean into because it gives them cover to make the other side seem unreasonable.
You know what is unreasonable? Being a fuckin’ Nazi.
Nazis in 1920s/1930s Germany, and fascists elsewhere in the first half of the 20th Century, didn’t just take power because they were violent, they were helped along the way by the quiet acquiescence of large portions of the population.
TLDR: by doing nothing in the 1920s and 1930s ordinary people, or ‘Little Nazis’, paved the way for Hitler and the Holocaust.
The ‘Little Nazis’ were the people who equivocated on matters because it was easier to either not take a position or stick their fingers in their ears, smush their eyes closed and pretend everything was a-ok because it was easy.
And this happens to Smart People™ too, which is why it worries me when yesterday journalist Bernard Hickey (
Bernard, mate, it took Joshua approximately 60 minutes of searching on Substack to find about +100 reprehensible publications. You have a huge following. You call yourself a journalist. Your stance on this does journalism a disservice. Do better, man.
But look, I get it. It’s easy to stay on Substack. It’s easy to ignore the rising tide of racism and intolerance. It’s easy to put your head in the sand and get on with it. Life is already hard without another existential threat looming over you.
But here’s the thing: it’s easy until it isn’t.
These ‘Little Nazis’ had the opportunity early on to disrupt the Nazi machine. They didn’t take it, which doesn’t necessarily make them bad people, but we need to learn from their lesson. Sometimes history doesn’t so much repeat as it does echo. Our situation today is eerily similar to 100 years ago, even down to the recent pandemic. We have massive income inequality, ongoing multiple conflicts between major powers, people are disengaged, inflation is spiking. It’s all fucking doom and gloom.
But I’m not asking Substack to solve racism (Nazis, TERFs, climate change denial etc).
I am asking Substack to not tolerate intolerance and to, when it is reported, take prompt action to remove it from their platform in line with their existing policy.
And that message — Nazis are not tolerated here — is an important message in and of itself.
Nazis are always going to Nazi, but taking a small stand now can stop a bigger problem in the future. Nazis are cowardly chickenshits, but the more they feel empowered the more violent they will get.
If Substack continues to allow Nazis to publish, distribute hate and to algorithmically create opportunities for people to get pulled into their orbit, all the while providing those Nazis with a steady income stream Substack contributes to and benefits from the (very probable) violent action that will (and is already) happening.
This is Substack's opportunity to stand up, because being neutral is not an option when it comes to Nazis.
Free speech cannot exist if other people are afraid to talk. This is the inherent paradox at the heart of free speech discourse and it's the exact reason why rightwing grifters lean into free speech as a concept.
Also, I’m not asking you to do much. I need you to be aware that there is most definitely a problem and you do have agency to resisit this current wave of fascism, even if it is just supporting your favourite Substackers to move off this platform.
What I am asking is that you stand against Nazis. When you see a Nazi doing Nazi shit shout till you can’t shout any more to let people know that it’s not okay. Same goes for other shitty behaviour from TERFs, and all the other Nazi aligned shitty things (eg Flat Earthers). If you have time: protest and counter-protest. Join your local Campaign Against Racism and Fascism or financially support the people who are fighting against these shit heels. There are lots of ways you can resist.
I’m giving you permission to be intolerant of intolerance.
I’m pretty sure, given this is only the second post and there are only 54 subscribers, most of you know who I am and how to get hold of me. If not, you can get in touch with me via this email address. I’ll keep this post up for one month and then I will close this account for good. I have no plans to start another newsletter but I am an occasional contributor to a number of other publications, so no doubt this won’t be the last you hear from This Is Not A Grift.
Karl Popper was a pretty cool dude. He moved from Austria to New Zealand in the 1930s to escape fascism (he tried to go to Australia but was refused entry because of his Jewish ancestry 🙃). While in New Zealand he wrote The Open Society and Its Enemies in which the ‘paradox of intolerance’ is mentioned as a footnote.
As we all know, the world is in peril. Climate change is ravaging our planet, our economic systems are collapsing and communities are crumbling. We stand poised at a moment where we can harness the power of emerging technologies like cryptocurrencies and other web3 innovations to fund and build modern infrastructure (both physical and community) where it is needed the most all the while capturing carbon and sequestering our future.
In our first edition of This is Not a Grift we analyse your latest Investment Opportunity1 SHYPTO, an innovative way of combining crypto, carbon capture, and community. It’s a simple idea that makes so much sense and we here at This is Not a Grift expect it will really take off (on an ocean near you).
If you’re not already signed up to This is Not a Grift subscribe now.
What is SHYPTO?
SHYPTO is the world’s first Seastead-based climate change combating crypto project.
Wave, wind and solar energy is harnessed to power crypto mining and other web3 services.
Waste heat and sun grow algae for food production and carbon sequestration.
SHYPTO provides housing, jobs, and community for workers creating a new economic model that is good for the planet.
The business model
Provide mining, hosting and other web3 blockchain services from inside a competitive legal jurisdiction (AKA International Waters)
Sequester carbon in algae to create carbon credits on international markets
Sell as a nutritious and environmentally friendly food source
Create housing infrastructure for immediate sale and ongoing rental income
Reinvest profits to build more SHYPTO complexes across the seven seas
Crypto has been perceived as an environmentally hazardous joke – this business model turns it on its head creating communities and combating climate change.
SHYPTO is a paradigm shift for web3, climate change, and society.
There are currently no direct competitors to SHYPTO.
Other Seastead projects focus on libertarian ideals of ‘freedom’ or act as tax havens – they have not seen the potential in truly challenging climate change and the collapse of communities.
SHYPTO Alpha
Planning is already underway for SHYPTO Alpha.
Initial designs for our first facility are already well progressed.
Partnerships with research facilities and construction companies are being explored.
Due to the poor management of the “metaverse” we have a lot of mis”coin”ceptions about web3 and crypto to overcome. Reimagining our environmental future will require a significant spend on brand and storytelling.
We are raising $USD2.5m in seed funding.
This will be used to
Validate the business concept
Algae procurement
Secure construction contracts for SHYPTO Alpha
Phase one marketing and awareness campaign
The SHYPTO Team has more than 30 years experience and Bird Hat Grift Club – the world’s most comprehensive NFT project – is our official partner.
You can get in on the seafloor of this amazing investment opportunity2 by subscribing to This is Not a Grift, sharing the newsletter, and/or commenting below – the more publicity this gets, the more chance you have of seeing a return on investment3.
Summary
SHYPTO is undoubtably an Investment Opportunity that, in the spirit of This is Not a Grift, will make you feel richer, livelier, and smarter. As mentioned on our About page we’ll be bringing you more 100% legitimate and trustworthy investment, health, and life advice4 soon.
In the meantime, please subscribe, share, and comment with your thoughts about SHYPTO.
We know Finding Science Fact-based Health Tips and getting the insider knowledge from the Stock Market Businesses Men and Health Doctors takes time. Sitting through lengthy webinars and swaping fax messages with some of the world’s Richest Human People takes even longer. But in order to get the most truthfully adjacent information at the fastest speeds straight to your inbox and into your very Smart Brain (which is behind a very Handsome Face, I must say) makes it all worth it so you can feel richer, livelier, and smarter.